Unpacking the ‘Black-Owned’ Label: A Surprising Twist in Cannabis Consumer Behavior

The cannabis industry, now a multi-billion-dollar market, thrives on branding that resonates with diverse audiences. A recent study published in the Journal of Consumer Research has revealed a fascinating dynamic: labeling cannabis products as “Black-owned” significantly boosts appeal among white consumers, but fails to generate the same enthusiasm among Black consumers. This unexpected finding sheds light on consumer psychology, expertise stereotypes, and the challenges of equity in a rapidly growing sector. As cannabis products online, cannabis products wholesale, and cannabis products white label continue to shape the market, understanding these nuances is critical for brands aiming to navigate this complex landscape.

Expertise Stereotypes and Consumer Perceptions

The study, led by Chethana Achar of Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management, surveyed Black professionals in the cannabis industry and measured expertise stereotypes among consumers. It found that both Black and white participants viewed Black entrepreneurs as “stereotypical experts” in cannabis, a perception rooted in cultural associations rather than empirical evidence. For white consumers, this stereotype translates into heightened credibility when they see a “Black-owned” label, increasing their intent to purchase cannabis products by 21% in clickthrough rates for psychedelics ads, as observed in a separate Facebook ad analysis. Conversely, Black consumers showed no increased interest in cannabis labeled as “Black-owned,” though they were more likely to engage with “Black-owned” candy products. This divergence suggests that stigma within the Black community may suppress in-group identification with cannabis, a product historically tied to negative stereotypes and legal repercussions.

The Role of Stigma in Shaping Preferences

Stigma plays a pivotal role in these findings. For Black consumers, the “Black-owned” label on cannabis may evoke associations with systemic issues, such as disproportionate incarceration rates during the War on Drugs. The study notes that while white consumers perceive “Black-owned” cannabis as culturally authentic, Black consumers may distance themselves from products that reinforce stigmatized narratives. This is particularly evident in the data: “Black-owned” labeling increased Black participants’ intent to consume candy but not cannabis, while white participants showed the opposite trend, favoring cannabis over candy. As cannabis products online gain traction, brands must grapple with these differing perceptions to craft messaging that resonates without alienating key demographics.

Implications for Cannabis Branding Strategies

For businesses operating in the cannabis products wholesale and cannabis products white label sectors, these findings pose both opportunities and challenges. White-labeling, where a manufacturer produces a generic product rebranded by another company, is a cost-effective way to enter the market. However, the study suggests that slapping a “Black-owned” label on these products may not universally boost appeal. White consumers, driven by perceptions of expertise, may flock to such brands, but Black consumers require a different approach, perhaps one that emphasizes quality, innovation, or community impact over racial identity. The cannabis industry, projected to reach $197.74 billion by 2028, cannot afford to misstep in its branding efforts, especially as competition intensifies.

The Equity Conundrum in Cannabis Entrepreneurship

The study raises critical questions about equity in the cannabis industry. Despite social equity programs aimed at increasing diversity, Black-owned businesses remain underrepresented. In Los Angeles, only 11 of the first 100 retail cannabis licenses went to Black applicants, highlighting systemic barriers. The “Black-owned” label was intended to signal support for these entrepreneurs, but the research suggests it may inadvertently cater to white consumer preferences rather than empowering Black communities. For cannabis products online, where visibility is key, brands must balance authenticity with broad appeal. The study’s lead author, Achar, emphasized that “equity policies alone are not enough to ensure market success for Black entrepreneurs,” pointing to the need for deeper structural changes.

Cultural Shifts and Future Possibilities

The research also hints at a potential shift in attitudes. If cannabis were reframed as “culture-forward” rather than stigmatized, the “Black-owned” label might resonate more with Black consumers. This is not a far-fetched idea, given the growing acceptance of cannabis, with 74% of consumers supporting non-cannabis brands aligning with cannabis culture during events like 4/20. As cannabis products wholesale markets expand, brands could leverage this cultural momentum to destigmatize the plant, particularly for marginalized communities. The study’s authors note that societal attitudes are evolving, and future research could explore how these changes impact consumer behavior.

Navigating the Online and Wholesale Cannabis Landscape

The rise of cannabis products online has democratized access but complicated branding. Consumers browsing digital marketplaces encounter a flood of options, from flower to edibles to cannabis products white label offerings. The study’s findings suggest that “Black-owned” labels could be a differentiator for white audiences, but brands must tread carefully to avoid tokenism. In the wholesale sector, where bulk products are rebranded for retail, authenticity matters. Companies like HybridLA and Riverview Farms, which prioritize organic practices and community roots, demonstrate how Black-owned businesses can carve out a niche without relying solely on racial labeling. These firms offer turnkey solutions, from cultivation to distribution, that appeal to retailers seeking quality and story-driven products.

A Call for Nuanced Marketing Approaches

The cannabis industry stands at a crossroads. The “Black-owned” label, while powerful, is not a one-size-fits-all solution. White consumers’ enthusiasm for these products reflects a desire for authenticity, but Black consumers’ lukewarm response underscores the need for marketing that transcends stereotypes. Brands selling cannabis products online must invest in storytelling that highlights quality, innovation, and social impact. Those in the cannabis products wholesale and cannabis products white label markets should partner with manufacturers who understand these dynamics, ensuring that branding aligns with consumer values. The study’s data—showing a 21% clickthrough increase for “Black-owned” ads among white consumers—offers a clear signal: strategic labeling can drive engagement, but only if paired with cultural sensitivity.

Looking Ahead: Redefining Success in Cannabis

As the cannabis industry evolves, so must its approach to equity and branding. The Journal of Consumer Research study is a wake-up call, urging businesses to rethink how “Black-owned” labels are used. For Black entrepreneurs, success lies in crafting brands that resonate universally while honoring community roots. For white consumers, supporting these businesses means moving beyond stereotypes to value quality and impact. And for the industry as a whole, the challenge is clear: create a market where diversity thrives, not just in labels but in ownership and opportunity. As cannabis products online, wholesale, and white label continue to shape the future, the path forward demands creativity, empathy, and a commitment to breaking down barriers—one brand at a time.

Discover D Squared WorldWide, your trusted source for premium cannabis products wholesale. Our high-quality, white-label offerings empower retailers to stand out in the booming $197.74 billion cannabis market. With authentic branding that resonates across diverse audiences, D Squared WorldWide delivers turnkey solutions—from cultivation to distribution—crafted with innovation and community impact in mind. Unlike generic labels, our products reflect expertise and cultural sensitivity, ensuring broad appeal. Elevate your inventory with D Squared WorldWide’s organic, story-driven cannabis solutions. Ready to grow your brand? Schedule a call today to explore our wholesale opportunities and drive success!

Reference:

1. Assanangkornchai, S., Thaikla, K., Talek, M., & Saingam, D. (2022). Medical cannabis use in thailand after its legalization: a respondent-driven sample survey. Peerj, 10, e12809. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.12809

2. Carliner, H., Brown, Q., Sarvet, A., & Hasin, D. (2017). Cannabis use, attitudes, and legal status in the u.s.: a review. Preventive Medicine, 104, 13-23. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ypmed.2017.07.008

Chan, G. and Hall, W. (2020). Estimation of the proportion of population cannabis consumption in australia that is accounted for by daily users using monte carlo simulation. Addiction, 115(6), 1182-1186. https://doi.org/10.1111/add.14909